Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility Pet Food Supply Store Brooklyn NY - My Natural Pet

  Find Your Store

Brooklyn

 8318 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
  (718) 333-5678
Open Today Until 5:00 pm
In-Store Pickup, Curbside Pickup, Local Delivery, Same Day Delivery, No Contact Delivery Available

My Natural Pet
Healthy Pet Food in Brooklyn

We Open Monday at 12:00 PM
8318 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY, 11209
          4.8/5 (View Recent Reviews)
About Us Contact Us

Buy Online for In-Store Pickup

Our Mission at My Natural Pet

At My Natural Pet, our mission is simple: Making healthier choices available to pet parent at an affordable price. Just like people, our pets need a healthy body, mind, and soul. Our specialty pet care products can help prevent or manage a variety of health conditions— allowing them feel their very best. 

Make sure to stop by for the best pet grooming, high quality pet food & supplies, and healthy treats for dogs! Or, take advantage of our local delivery! We are happy to provide local delivery services to Bay Ridge, Dyker Heights, and Bensonhurst residents.

Highest Quality Pet Food Brands in Brooklyn

My Natural Pet has everything your pet needs to live a healthier, happier life. We only carry the best, all natural pet food brands. 95% of pet owners say pets are part of the family -- so let's feed them like family!
12
View All Brands

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK

Like My Natural Pet on Facebook for great photos of our local pets, pet groomings, deals, events, and more near Brooklyn!

 Like Us

What My Natural Pet Customers Are Saying

We love all of our happy customers from local areas near Brooklyn, including Dyker Heights, Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst, Mapleton, Boro Park, Bath Beach, Gravesend, Sunset Park, Mill Basin, Park Slope, Dumbo, Cobble Hill, Kensington, Carroll Gardens, Staten Island, and more! 
Maryam Eskarous
2025-05-16

I absolutely love shopping at My Natural Pet! The store is always clean, well-organized, and fully stocked with high-quality, healthy options for my pet. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and friendly—they truly care about animals and it shows. They always take the time to answer my questions and help me find exactly what I need. I also appreciate their selection of natural and holistic products—it gives me peace of mind knowing I’m giving my pet the best. Highly recommend this place to any pet parent!

Kristen Pound
2025-02-01

Whenever I come to visit family, I stop by My Natural Pet so I may stock up for my cats' dietary needs. The store is very clean and has a wonderful variety of quality foods and treats for my fur babies. I am absolutely a lifelong customer. Thanks for always having a very unique selection.

Shari MPD
2025-02-01

My Natural pet is our Morkies favorite place to shop for their morkie needs! This store has high quality dog food, such as raw (dogs thriving on raw) meat, quality treats, and fun doggie, cats and bird toys! Margot is accommodating to any questions, needs, or concerns. Communication is important for them to guide and help you around this specialty boutique pet store. Daisy and Cody are so thankful for this store being in our neighborhood. From one block away, while walking there, these pups get super excited and drag us straight to My Natural Pet store with excitement! Bring your dogs and pets here for their needs, you won't regret it! 💗🐶💗🐶💗

Victor Gonzalez
2025-01-12

Recently took my dog in to get groomed. Phenomenal job. I highly recommend coming here.

Gina Scialla
2025-01-11

This store offers such an amazing variety of quality products for your pets. Their staff is knowledgeable about their product offerings and were VERY helpful in assisting me in making intelligent choices for my fur babies. The store is immaculate, they offer grooming, and I needed a product which they did not have in stock, so they ordered it for me on the spot. I will definitely be supporting this local for all of pets needs, check them out.

View All Reviews Write A Review
Come visit our pet supply store in Brooklyn, NY specializing in quality food, treats, and supplies for cats, dogs, birds, fish, and small pets.