Find Your Store

Brooklyn

 8318 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
  (718) 333-5678
Open Today Until 6:00 pm
In-Store Pickup, Curbside Pickup, Local Delivery, Same Day Delivery, No Contact Delivery Available

Cat Food and Supplies in Brooklyn, NY

Shop Now Contact Us

Buy Online for In-Store Pickup

Feed Your Cat Well

Here at My Natural Pet, we provide cat food and items for your kitty. Our assortment of cat food may help deal with physical health concerns for example, allergy symptoms, GI issues, urinary tract health, body weight control, grain sensitivities, and more. Our yummy cat treat choices are a terrific reward for your cat. We additionally stock a selection of pet cat and kitten items. Come by our pet shop in Brooklyn, NY

What My Natural Pet Customers Are Saying

We love all of our happy customers from local areas near Brooklyn, including Dyker Heights, Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst, Mapleton, Boro Park, Bath Beach, Gravesend, Sunset Park, Mill Basin, Park Slope, Dumbo, Cobble Hill, Kensington, Carroll Gardens, Staten Island, and more! 
Tara Chan
2024-03-13

Excellent pet store! Margot was friendly and knowledgeable.

Lana P
2024-02-14

We have been using My Natural Pet store for a number of years to shop for our now 10-year old Long Coat German Shepherd. The store is excellent. The product selection is top-notch – products are natural, chemical-free and organic. When you shop for your pet here, you can be assured that they will get the best stuff on the market. Everyone is very friendly. Margo - the owner - is also extremely knowledgeable about every product and company that produces it. If you have questions or concerns, she always spends a lot of time with your discussing your issues and making great recommendations. We will certainly continue coming here.

TOM89999
2024-01-24

Love My Natural Pet. Lexi loves the wet food and her new tunnel toy that my girlfriend bought recently. The Halloween and Christmas family pictures are so awesome. The staff there are terrific.

TOM89999
2024-01-24

Love My Natural Pet. Lexi loves the wet food and her new tunnel toy that my girlfriend bought recently. The Halloween and Christmas family pictures are so awesome. The staff there are terrific.

Carolyn vk
2024-01-22

Such a sweet and resourceful store. Not only do they have a wide range of healthy pet food options, I’m always finding extra snacks and toys for my cats. Not to mention the owner has the best cat behavior advice! Super thank you for the visitor anxiety tips.

View All Reviews Write A Review
Come visit our pet supply store in Brooklyn, NY specializing in quality food, treats, and supplies for cats, dogs, birds, fish, and small pets.