Find Your Store

Brooklyn

 8318 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
  (718) 333-5678
Open Today Until 6:00 pm
In-Store Pickup, Curbside Pickup, Local Delivery, Same Day Delivery, No Contact Delivery Available

My Natural Pet
Healthy Pet Food in Brooklyn

OPEN TODAY UNTIL 6:00 PM
8318 5th Ave
Brooklyn, NY, 11209
          4.8/5 (View Recent Reviews)
About Us Contact Us

Buy Online for In-Store Pickup

Our Mission at My Natural Pet

At My Natural Pet, our mission is simple: Making healthier choices available to pet parent at an affordable price. Just like people, our pets need a healthy body, mind, and soul. Our specialty pet care products can help prevent or manage a variety of health conditions— allowing them feel their very best. 

Make sure to stop by for the best pet grooming, high quality pet food & supplies, and healthy treats for dogs! Or, take advantage of our local delivery! We are happy to provide local delivery services to Bay Ridge, Dyker Heights, and Bensonhurst residents.

Highest Quality Pet Food Brands in Brooklyn

My Natural Pet has everything your pet needs to live a healthier, happier life. We only carry the best, all natural pet food brands. 95% of pet owners say pets are part of the family -- so let's feed them like family!
12
View All Brands

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK

Like My Natural Pet on Facebook for great photos of our local pets, pet groomings, deals, events, and more near Brooklyn!

 Like Us

What My Natural Pet Customers Are Saying

We love all of our happy customers from local areas near Brooklyn, including Dyker Heights, Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst, Mapleton, Boro Park, Bath Beach, Gravesend, Sunset Park, Mill Basin, Park Slope, Dumbo, Cobble Hill, Kensington, Carroll Gardens, Staten Island, and more! 
Jeannie Gobaira
2023-12-06

My dogs really liked shopping here. I loved shopping here. I can’t wait to go back. This store is very pet friendly and has wide aisles; large pet strollers fit easily and so do wheelchairs/walkers. The store is well lit and very clean. I specifically came for advice with balanced meals, I’m now cooking for my dogs. There is a good selection of meal additives, toppers and human grade pet foods. My other reason for shopping at My Natural Pet was to get a harness for a hard to fit dachshund. Margo tried on every harness and ultimately took my name and number for when his comes in, he’s a specialty order. My special boy. Next, matching outfits for the holiday season. This was so much fun. The dogs tried on a bunch of stuff- see pics- if you have ever seen Last Holiday with Queen Latifah - that was the vibe in the store. It was FABULOUS. They were offered little complimentary treats. The store has the best overall vibe as far as pet stores in the neighborhood. We did get a few things off list. There was no hard sell, we just could not resist, Frank Sinatra helped himself to a reindeer toy. It’s nice when dogs can pick out there own toys and treats. It was more fun than Chewy. Sashay tried on a few dresses and is coming back for pics with Santa in the green plaid one. We bought three sweaters, one dress, two treats, one toy, meal additives and spent about $100.

Siobhan Odonnell
2023-11-18

Really good selection of items for all pets.

Kaylin Cardenas
2023-07-26

this place is amazing my mom and i came for an event and fell in love with the cats and now have adopted one. they are so helpful here and know what they are talking about i strongly suggest coming here

Margaret NOLAN
2023-07-22

Margo and her amazing team are fantastic. They are always friendly and helpful. Their prices are great and I have fun with the dog and cat toys. The fact that they support rescues by holding adoption events AND also host monthly vaccine clinics makes it even better.

farrell seger
2023-07-22

this is the best pet store in brooklyn! every employee is so incredibly helpful and knowledgeable, and i really feel like i am feeding my animals the best food and getting the absolute best advice here. i also love that this place is woman owned! margo, the owner, is always ready to help me out and you can tell she has years of experience. i also love all their fun toys and treats! highly recommend! ❤️

View All Reviews Write A Review
Come visit our pet supply store in Brooklyn, NY specializing in quality food, treats, and supplies for cats, dogs, birds, fish, and small pets.