About My Natural Pet

Like I said on Yelp - this is my new favorite store. It’s immediately obvious when you enter that this place is very clean and organized, well-stocked but not overwhelming, and fun. I came to ask for food suggestions and Patrick helped me - he’s sincere, friendly, personable, caring, and patient. He gave my puppy lots of love and was the most helpful person I’ve come across with pet questions. It’s clear he is knowledgeable and he helped me choose a food that’s healthy and natural - my pup devoured the first bowl (Afterward I looked up studies on this food brand and it’s legit). Also I respect that the store’s laid out to ensure pets are happy too - my pup had a blast and chose her own cute toy shaped like an avocado. Thank you! And I love that today is a their pet adoption event - (I saw an IG post from the Bay Ridge BID about it, which is why I came looking for this new store). This team truly cares about animal welfare!

A caring pet store, and resonable prices

I really enjoy going to this pet store. The people are great. The selection of all natural pet products is amazing.

Great little local pet store! They've helped us take care of our cat without fail. Highly recommended.

Great addition to 5th Avenue! Our dog Zoe loves the treats we get from here - especially the cow ears. We were given some commercial cow ears for Zoe but after each ear made her sick we got rid of them. The only ears Zoe gets will be from My Natural Pet!